Abstract：Brain functional imaging technology has been widely used in clinical research, especially in brain injury, chronic nerve pain syndrome, cognitive dysfunction, and psychiatric diseases. With the establishment and expansion of neuroimaging datasets, it is possible to further read the privacy information of all human brain activities in the future, and with cloud data processing and the establishment of various artificial intelligence prediction models, it has seriously involved the principles of respect and security in ethics. This paper mainly discusses the issues of informed consent and data security in the clinical application of brain functional imaging technology and proposes application specifications and protection principles.
唐烨真,苗加庆,杜涛明. 脑功能成像技术在临床医学应用中的伦理问题研究[J]. 中国校医, 2024, 38(1): 72-75.
TANG Yezhen, MIAO Jiaqing, DU Taoming. Research on ethical issues of brain functional imaging technology application in clinical medicine. Chinese Journal of School Doctor, 2024, 38(1): 72-75.
[1] Bennett MR,Hatton S,Hermens DF,et al.Behavior, neuropsycho-logy and fMRI[J]. Prog Neurobiol,2016(145-146):1-25. [2] 杜小霞,秦朝霞.磁共振功能成像回顾与展望[J].磁共振成像,2019,10(10):721-726. [3] 王湘彬,许晓雯,王培军.轻度认知功能障碍的多模态脑功能成像[J].诊断学理论与实践,2017,16(2):131-136. [4] 徐家华,周莹,罗文波,等.人类情绪发展认知神经科学:面向未来心理健康与教育[J].中国科学:生命科学,2021,51(6):663-678. [5] Watanabe T,Sasaki Y,Shibata K,et al. Advances in fMRI real-time neurofeedback[J]. Trends Cogn Sci,2017,21(12):997-1010. [6] Guldenmund P,Vanhaudenhuyse A,Boly M,et al. A default modeof brain function in altered states of consciousness[J]. Arch Ital Biol,2012,150(2-3):107-121. [7] Yang H,Wu QZ,Guo LT,et al.Abnormal spontaneous brain activityin medication-naive ADHD children:A resting state fMRI study[J].Neurosci Lett,2011,502(2):89-93. [8] Liu C,Xue Z,Palaniyappan L,et al.Abnormally increased and inco-herent resting-state activity is shared between patients with schizo-phrenia and their unaffected siblings[J]. Schizophrenia Research,2016,171(1-3):158-165. [9] Wang W,Hou J,Qian S,et al. Aberrant regional neural fluctuationsand functional connectivity in generalized anxiety disorder revealedby resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging[J]. NeurosciLett,2016(624):78-84. [10] Ma Y,Zhao Q,Xu T,et al. Resting state functional brain imagingin obsessive-compulsive disorder across genders[J]. World J BiolPsychiatry,2022,23(3):191-200. [11] Zhu Z,Huang T,Zhen Z,et al. From sMRI to task-fMRI: A unifiedgeometric deep learning framework for cross-modal brain anatomo-functional mapping[J]. Med Image Anal,2023(83):102681. [12] Feinberg DA,Moeller S,Smith SM,et al. Multiplexed echo planarimaging for sub-second whole brain FMRI and fast diffusionimaging[J]. PLoS One,2010,5(12):e15710. [13] 张俊,张恒柱,张洪英,等.轻度脑损伤病人任务态fMRI脑区激活:元分析[J].中国微侵袭神经外科杂志,2021,26(3):105-109. [14] 杜婷婷,陈颍川,朱冠宇,等.基于大脑形态学特征的机器学习方法预测帕金森病患者的抑郁症状[J].临床神经外科杂志,2021,18(2):121-124,130. [15] Sako W,Murakami N,Izumi Y,et al.MRI can detect nigral volumeloss in patients with Parkinson’s disease: Evidence from a meta-analysis[J]. J Parkinsons Dis,2014,4(3):405-411. [16] 比彻姆,邱卓思.生命医学伦理原则[M]. 5版.李伦,译.北京:北京大学出版社,2014:1. [17] Racine E,Illes J. Emerging ethical challenges in advanced neuroi-maging research: Review, recommendations and research agenda[J]. J Empir Res Hum Res Ethics,2007,2(2):1-10. [18] 李雪锋.个人信息保护中知情同意原则的困境和应对措施[J].法制博览,2022(33):3. [19] Di Martino A,Yan CG,Li Q,et al.The autism brain imaging dataexchange: Towards a large-scale evaluation of the intrinsic brainarchitecture in autism[J]. Mol Psychiatry,2014,19(6):659-667. [20] Craddock RC,Jbabdi S,Yan CG,et al. Imaging human connecto-mes at the macroscale[J]. Nat Methods,2013,10(6):524-539. [21] Charles AS,Falk B,Turner N,et al.Toward community-driven bigopen brain science: Open big data and tools for structure, function,and genetics[J]. Annu Rev Neurosci,2020(43):441-464. [22] Marek S,Tervo-Clemmens B,Calabro FJ,et al. Reproducible brain-wide association studies require thousands of individuals[J]. Nature,2022,603(7902):654-660. [23] Yang Z,Zuo XN,Wang P,et al. discover homogeneous subject (sub)groups by reproducibility of their intrinsic connectivity networks[J].Neuroimage,2012,63(1):403-414. [24] Nooner KB,Colcombe SJ,Tobe RH,et al. The NKI-Rocklandsample: A model for accelerating the pace of discovery science inpsychiatry[J]. Front Neurosci,2012(6):152. [25] Wang YW,Chen X,Yan CG. Comprehensive evaluation of harmo-nization on functional brain imaging for multisite data-fusion[J].Neuroimage,2023(274):120089. [26] Bowman FD. Brain imaging analysis[J]. Annu Rev Stat Appl,2014(1):61-85. [27] Shteynberg G,Hirsh JB,Wolf W,et al.Theory of collective mind[J].Trends Cogn Sci,2023,27(11):1019-1031. [28] Rommelfanger KS, Jeong SJ, Ema A, et al. Neuroethics questionsto guide ethical research in the international brain initiatives[J].Neuron,2018,100(1):19-36. [29] Zhou Z,Pu MM.Ethics in pace with scientific progress[J]. NationalScience Review,2018,5(3):299. [30] 李萍萍,马涛,张鑫,等.脑科学伦理问题和治理探析[J].中国医学伦理学,2019,32(12):1580-1585. [31] Wang Y,Yin J,Wang G,et al. Responsibility and sustainability inbrain science, technology, and neuroethics in China-a culture-oriented perspective[J]. Neuron,2019,101(3):375-379. [32] 李会娟,苑杰,武阳丰.研究者发起的临床研究中常见伦理问题及监管考量[J].医学与哲学,2022,43(7):6-10.
2024, Vol. 38 
